Wednesday, June 15, 2005

Comparing two pairs of movies

While idly looking through my blog I discovered that my last 6 posts were all book reviews or about books. Suddenly I realized that my blog was becoming too bookish for even myself and hence this post on few movies. I have seen quite few good old Tamil movies of late and wanted to comment on them, but that would be on a different post. Since I like comparing, I would comment on two pairs of films – similar in their themes, but starkly different in the way they were produced, one of them is ‘big’ and the other is ‘small’.

To keep the discussion as global as possible I would start with a recent Hindi movie – “Kaal”. Boasting some leading actors, good locations and a ‘different’ script this was, I guess, released with quite a lot of hype. But through out the movie I could only pity the technicians who had worked for the good locations, different camera angles and background score (which though too loud, would have been good if used properly) on essentially trying to prop up a weak story and screenplay. In fact, I feel that if all these technical elements were under played or at least limitedly used the movie would have been more tolerable. There was absolutely no scene in the movie which was truly terrifying and there was not even much thrill. Of course I didn’t know who the murderer was, but I didn’t care! And the ending was as insipid as it could be - a murder mystery conveniently blaming a ghost!

The sharp turning camera angles, the unnecessarily loud background score and the skimpily clad ladies (why do you wear such a dress in a forest - to get more mosquito bites?) were all constant irritations. It was the Hindi movie I was seeing after quite some time and I thoroughly regretted the choice. More irritating was that it was being hyped as a new generation Hindi movie! (I had felt the same about “Bhoot” though to a much lesser extent). The movie seems to have deservedly flopped in box office, proving that people can’t be cheated too much by glitz and glamour (of course they can be cheated to some extent, which is proved by the success of “big budget” masala movies).

Coming to this movie’s counterpart it is a relatively little known Tamil movie called “Whistle”. I saw this in television recently. I think it was released very normally and succeeded to some extent. Now I don’t claim this as a classic thriller movie. But it was thrilling and thrilling till the end. And it didn’t have to resort to stupid techniques like a ghost being a murderer (in fact this is ridiculed in the movie). Surprisingly, for all those who regard genre movies very highly, this wasn’t a pure thriller – but had a college group and romance as a background. I can’t comment much on the romance part since I missed something like first 30 minutes of the movie and anyway most of the characters were dead in the end! But it didn’t obstruct the thrill at all. The songs did spoil the thrill somewhat and at least two could have been cut down (there are also some nice and popular songs in the movie). But the last half an hour or so was totally focused and thrilling.

What I expect in a thriller movie is that the identity of the killer (or any aggressor) should be a surprise not easily guessable but still should be logically justifiable (match with all the clues in the movie). This was quite well done here, since any one person being killer would be too difficult here, two people are shown as killers. And their motive is justified by a rather chilling flashback, which also justifies the title and which reminds me of “Kudaikkul Mazhai”, but that is a digression. In “Kaal” this has no meaning since the aggressor is a ghost who can do anything! Sound effects are very well used in the movie, with something happening in silence producing the most shock. All the actors were new, but did seem to perform their roles well. The director(s) are JD-Jerry, faintly familiar, but I don’t recall how. In short, another “small” movie which wins hands down over a “big” movie.

My next comparison would be much more critical and may not be liked by many Shankar fans. It is between his movie, the over-hyped “Boys” (which did very average in the box office) and “Thullavatho Ilamai” (title is hard to translate literally, but one try is Springing youth), which was a relatively unknown film when released, but became a huge hit. Both are concerned about pangs of growing up, difficulties a set of youth face and the how they finally overcome all this. Both were accused as being almost soft porn movies. But there ends the similarity. Now I would like to exclude one factor from this comparison – sex in both these movies. Personally I believe that, sex is shown in a much more subtle and mature way in “Thullavatho Ilamai” than “Boys”, but this may be wrong since I saw the latter in theatre and the former in television.

“Boys” shows the travails faced by the youngsters when they run away from home, but finally they are heroes and hence triumph in a short time after facing all the hurdles. The love story here is quite silly, being based on such silly scenes like hero running naked in Anna salai for proving his love and earthquake helping the lovers to unite! But still they are the hero and heroine and must unite and live happily in the end. In short I feel it romanticizes infatuation as love and chance success as success gained by hard work. How many singers have come up so quickly in life and how many of us have such special talents like singing? Basing such things to show that a group of runaway teenagers are successful only shows the eagerness of the director to have a happy ending, even if it is unrealistic. I dislike Shankar’s movies mainly for these – in fact I would say “Indian” was the only good movie he has done. “Mudhalvan” and “Gentleman” are movies with a good theme but messed up throughout and in climax, respectively. The other three including “Boys” don’t even warrant a mention, as they have nothing more than an average movie.

In contrast “Thullavatho Ilamai” is starkly realistic. Here also youngsters run away from home and get to discover themselves and the world. But both these experiences are not pleasant, so they return back to their homes – and the movie effectively ends there. This also has lead pair who are initially friends, but due to their parents’ suspicion and due to their close stay when running away, have sex. But the movie clearly shows that this is the result of their momentary lust and hence they live as before when they return home. In fact to add emphasis it is shown that the boy, not wanting to face her, left the school and hasn’t met her since. And the rest of the youngsters stay in their homes and come up in life the hard way. In fact the climax of hero and heroine not meeting ever after surprised me, as I thought the climax of a commercially successful Tamil movie can’t be so realistic. On the down side, the movie happens to be a bit didactic with some messages for both parents and children (not that Boys didn’t have this). The movie blames the parents for most of the faults, but that is justifiable for the parents shown. Though it doesn’t have the glitz of “Boys”, it has a very good musical score by Yuvan Shankar Raja and of course direction and screenplay are most impressive of all. Kasturiraja is the director, though it is said that his son, Selvaraghavan, now a popular director played more than a helping hand in this. The lead pair was unknown then, but now Danush is a leading hero.

One reason for matured handling here could be that these youngsters are school final year students and are hence younger than even those shown in “Boys”. But even this can’t justify the totally unrealistic manner in which script is handled in “Boys”. As an aside, I finally confirmed that the beautiful song “Theenda Theenda” was in fact during love making of the lead pair. It was of course cut off in television, but I got the initial music in the scene. Without doubt, it is the most decent, subtle and pleasant song I have heard for a love making scene. No wonder that when I am asked as to what is wrong in showing sex and glamour in movies, my only refrain is to show them only when important to the story and in an enjoyable and not repelling manner.

There are some more movies on which I want to comment and I would list them down so that at least I can remember them – K.B’s “Arangettram” – though I didn’t see this fully, it was already bold enough to shake me, “Pagalil Oru Iravu” - a good climax, K.B’s “Sindhu Bairavi” – a good but controversial movie, Bharathiraja’s “Padhinaaru Vaidhinile” - a good movie worth its reputation as a classic. I am trying desperately to watch classics like “Nizhalgal”, “Oru Nadigai Nadagam Parkiraal”(An actress sees a play - what a title! It's self-referential!) and all Jayakanthan story movies, “Mogamul”, but I am not able to rent or even buy these VCDs or DVDs in Bangalore (or are they available in Chennai?). Can somebody help me please!!

81 comments:

யாத்திரீகன் said...

விசில் படத்துக்கு இப்படி ஒரு நல்ல விமர்சனமா ?! நம்பமுடியவில்லை. ஒரு logic-உம் இல்லாத ஒரு குப்பை படம் என்று வேண்டுமானால் சொல்லுவேன், நீங்கள் சொன்ன மாதிரி அந்த முடிவுக்கு மட்டும் ஒரு அட, ஆனால் அந்த climax-க்கு ஒரு கொட்டு

nivas said...

Senthil,
I dont get why you feel the movie is junk. Perhaps i saw it without any expectation and that is why it felt good. But still i dont see anything which is totally illogical. The murders appear far fetched, but is not something that can't be done with good planning. And the flashback is also far-fetched but is nothing that can't happen to a sensitive girl.

mia said...

I appreciate your information on Hindi Movie. I just bookmarked your site and will be back regulalry to keep on top of it. Please check out my blog on Hindi Movie Exposed - I'd really appreciate it

jon said...

We are trying to find good yahoo movie to take the kids this weekend. Good yahoo movie reviews are hard to find

I just stumbled onto your blog while looking. Seems to happen to me a lot since I am a knowledge mooch LOL

Thanks

Mukund said...

Neat & appealing reviews.

Read most of your movie review posts and was impressed. Movies should become more and more realistic. In this sense, I even don't like songs in movies (songs running in the background are absolutely fine). They kind of slow down the movie pace and give a unrealistic feeling. Maniratnam frankly admitted this in one if his recent interviews. May be you can think can of a separate post on this.

You might want to look at http://parallelcinema.blogspot.com/ which also gives some good reviews about realistic cinema.

Few more additions to list of KB movies you had listed - Thaneer Thaneer, Varumayin Niram Sikappu

Download Hindi Movie said...

Hi there ##NAME##. I was just browsing, looking for Download Movie Trailer related information and found your blog. Very nice! I have a Download Movie Trailer site. In addition to movie downloads, you can find options for downloading various movie players. Please visit, check it out and enjoy! : )

If you have a site similar to mine and would like to exchange links, please contact me through my website.

zuke said...

I loved your post! I came across your blog and it really caught my attention, Ill be sure to come back for more! Keep up the good work! jay chou music video download

Anonymous said...

I need a Riddle ASAP! i know this sounds extreamly werid but i need a riddle. Dont ask why just give me something!! thanks!









































[url=http://www.thedaytheearthstoodstill.org/]the day the earth stood still[/url]

Anonymous said...

I wish not agree on it. I think polite post. Expressly the appellation attracted me to read the unscathed story.

Anonymous said...

I've just recently bought Mt4 Protect and wanted to tell you guys about my experience with it.
I was worried about all the Metatrader virus's out there at the moment as I heard you can get them from downloading Expert Advisors from the internet.
While I don't download decompiled experts the last thing I want is some hacker getting my account details and draining my forex account as I have built it up into quite a bit of cash. That's why I purchased MT4 protect so it can stop my account from getting attacked. I think the price is well worth the protection I will receive
I purchased a copy at [url=http://www.mt4protect.com/] http://www.mt4protect.com/ [/url] via paypal and my product code was sent to me within 4 hours.
I installed it and its wicked! It works in the system tray and scans my computer in real time to detect any attacks.
The EA optimization tool is so great - you can allocate more memory to your MT4 terminal so your trades get executed faster! There are also heaps of registry tweaks and cleanup features that have tuned up my Windows 2000 computer.
With Trojans and virus attacks hitting Forex traders all the time now I definitely think that MT4 Protect is a worthwhile investment.

Anonymous said...

piracy affects porn but it's still winner during the crunch


----------------
interracial sex

Anonymous said...

Amiable dispatch and this enter helped me alot in my college assignement. Thank you as your information.

Anonymous said...

crazy idea i know but how do u think credit cruch affected porn?


----------------
interracialsex

Anonymous said...

Thank u :) take a look this emo boy style over this blog:
http://www.emo--boys.info

Anonymous said...

Good post and this enter helped me alot in my college assignement. Thank you as your information.

Anonymous said...

Sweet web site, I hadn’t come across blog.angelsfromabroad.com before in my searches!Carry on the fantastic work!.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://hairtyson.com]phentermine 37.5[/url] are tablets that help abridge fuselage weight. One of these tabs has to be captivated with ring false, round 20 minutes already a collation, twice a day.

Anonymous said...

soma muscle soma pills generic - soma drug history

Anonymous said...

buy soma buy somatropin online usa - order soma online no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy soma online buy soma online texas - what is in soma muscle relaxer

Anonymous said...

buy cheap soma pictures of soma pills - soma online no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy soma soma muscle relaxer breastfeeding - buy steroids somatropin

Anonymous said...

buy soma online where to buy soma cube - generic soma online

Anonymous said...

soma buy soma muscle relaxer high - order soma texas

Anonymous said...

buy soma buy soma no script - buy soma online usa

Anonymous said...

soma online pharmacy ativan soma drug interactions - kendrick lamar san diego soma tickets

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online generic cialis does not work - buy cialis today

Anonymous said...

cheap soma soma muscle relaxer identification - soma for muscle spasms

Anonymous said...

soma for sale the mission soma san diego restaurant - soma generic fedex no prescription

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol soma generic soma compound - buy soma online us pharmacy

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.payloansonline.com]payday advance loans[/url]
This is the best way to get all your health products online like green coffee, african mango, phen375 and others. Visit now

[url=http://provillushairl0ss.blinkweb.com/]Provillus Reviews[/url]

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol in florida buy tramadol soma - buy tramadol online us pharmacy

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol que es tramadol hcl 50 mg - buy tramadol 50 mg

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online buy cheap tramadol online no prescription - buy tramadol online no prescription cod

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax dosage weight - xanax online with mastercard

Anonymous said...

Brokersring.com - Learn how to turn $500 into $5,000 in a month!

[url=http://www.brokersring.com/]Make Money Online[/url] - The Secret Reveled with Binary Option

Binary Options is the way to [url=http://www.brokersring.com/]make money[/url] securely online

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax dosage airplane - drug rehab for xanax

Anonymous said...

xanax online negative effects xanax - buy xanax cheap

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol carisoprodol texas penalty group - overdose on carisoprodol

Anonymous said...

generic xanax medication given xanax overdose - how to order xanax without an rx

Anonymous said...

cheapest xanax where to buy xanax online no prescription - drug used get off xanax

Anonymous said...

tramadol online pharmacy tramadol vs codeine - ordertramadolonline

Anonymous said...

generic xanax buy xanax online for cheap - xanax high feel

Anonymous said...

tory burch bahfzavm トリーバーチ iphoneケース jochsjgm トリーバーチ バッグ hwheebfy トリーバーチ 財布 sdwuddlx トリーバーチ 店舗 hrtgpahb トリーバーチ 靴 dwmcahvj トリーバーチ jfdzhgrf トリーバーチ新作 vevkflhl

Anonymous said...

cheap toms shoes shreqido cheap toms zakjcipu toms coupon code dycswgsp toms on sale qwwawycs toms outlet panwsqkb toms sale hmnoqfjo toms shoes on sale rzkbgfmt toms shoes sale jmkzzhot toms shoes pemzokfe

Anonymous said...

michael kors bags ttkqhnib michael kors handbags vavzcucn michael kors outlet inyztibg michael kors purse rwioxyhd michael kors purses eaitcdoo michael kors sale feozjrax michael kors azkvlmau

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol online consultation - tramadol contraindications

Anonymous said...

botas ugg baratas hpuayvka botas ugg espa?a fiopfgpm botas ugg ihmrwgzn comprar ugg online xedjtsep ugg australia mbgilndq ugg baratas lsnlnzyj ugg espa?a zkpjdiwi ugg online safvruhd ugg qizuhtzy

Anonymous said...

michael kors bags tvtwftlf michael kors handbags lfwsryxb michael kors outlet blyhkmto michael kors purses juvjmlxo michael kors sale pyujhngo Michael Kors fugxpkoz

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol can you buy tramadol over the counter in usa - tramadol online american pharmacy

Anonymous said...

longchamp pas cher buhxeuki longchamp pliage zwccgxpt longchamp soldes ldbhoidc longchamp oowmzgsj longchamps fuvhxvof portefeuille longchamp apedaiae sac longchamp solde rtouvmpt sac longchamp zesapqgm sacoche longchamp knwxancs

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol withdrawal dogs - tramadol 50 mg medication

Anonymous said...

ghd nz rdcnodhh ghd nz sale aydfebob ghd ignnexyw

Anonymous said...

coach outlet ljdpcwrw coach usa fdjvpxjc coach factory outlet vvzacxit coach factory kniyswfx

Anonymous said...

cialis online order cialis daily use - cialis joint pain

Anonymous said...

xanax 0.5mg xanax withdrawal nausea - effects yellow xanax bars

Anonymous said...

billige uggs sbhesfry ugg norge ebsxoaus ugg sko qgdywrqz ugg wcsimrak uggs australia dizaezvt uggs norge azelejeh uggs p? nett aqhfhveq uggs sko bquqgavg uggs qgjohzmk

Anonymous said...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#51438 tramadol ultram recreational - can you order tramadol online legally

Anonymous said...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#30896 ultram side effects rash - tramadol 100 mg extended release

Anonymous said...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#23561 tramadol for dogs side effects - tramadol ultram seizures

Anonymous said...

tory burch hcdhfpya トリーバーチ iphoneケース cjizbyfm トリーバーチ バッグ ncbsxove トリーバーチ 財布 acxxvmus トリーバーチ 店舗 priisasc トリーバーチ 靴 ensmjvnd トリーバーチ uqpogneu トリーバーチ新作 tvvizkoe

Anonymous said...

cheap ugg boots lijkxrje cheap uggs mjxmyeaj ugg boots sale ifxjssil ugg boots uk kzbompxi ugg boots wgigfafe ugg sale vhfdlshk

Anonymous said...

Longchamp inxzfubm Longchamp Pas Cher dsdlamkz Sac Longchamp fyaxdhpz Longchamp Soldes wbnviicn Longchamps wyproijc

Anonymous said...

christian louboutin outlet wastisrf discount christian louboutin aibmovzm christian louboutin shoes oxfmrdec christian louboutin heels vvelivfi christian louboutin pumps wpmxdlno christian louboutin boots rxnfbgtl christian louboutin wedding xdjzxgmq

Anonymous said...

Coach Outlet xrhjuvnh Coach Factory Outlet lyyrftoi Coach Factory nzqiyltm Coach Outlet Online lvslhuyr Coach Outlet Sale txpzafck

Anonymous said...

botas ugg baratas blpeduks botas ugg espa?a rapfhynt botas ugg viixxfjo comprar ugg online gzsdhguj ugg australia trfwfbph ugg baratas enkxnzpe ugg espa?a ydvlqwpk ugg online vijdsajp ugg ibmrrnlo

Anonymous said...

bottes ugg pas cher tsexgljg bottes ugg thoxufrg chaussures ugg dssbtfkz ugg australia ltrpwhlt ugg france zanszebt ugg pas cher nddcajtn ugg jvmefghj

Anonymous said...

cheap nike air max 90 aamcnaib cheap nike air max prvxjuya nike air max 1 jaitmzha nike air max 90 sqsfudjw nike air max 95 qaolmugj nike air max rvnizfli nike free run ljwdqsev nike store uk fqkcoogx nike uk cepcwmbd

Anonymous said...

cheap toms shoes tqptcbak cheap toms oidvimli toms on sale opthcqgm toms outlet dlfpgpny toms sale cjwlbqge toms shoes on sale geddjvja toms shoes sale nhjfskwx toms shoes taisvtxv

Anonymous said...

ghd baratas iwussglq ghd españa qjjxvvma ghd planchas vynbjbjt ghd wrswgnnv planchas ghd segfhvkj

Anonymous said...

cheap nike air max 90 tpkquvtd cheap nike air max llmcfzzg nike air max 1 qcliljdg nike air max 90 fhuzauqf nike air max 95 cnqbxtip nike air max bhswepbv nike free run kalwuhlv nike store uk pernwxcw nike uk mkiizogi

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol can buy tramadol online usa - tramadol 50 mg high

Anonymous said...

klonopin without prescription 2mg klonopin high dose - klonopin overdose much too much

Anonymous said...

cheap carisoprodol carisoprodol 350 mg cost - carisoprodol images

Anonymous said...

http://southcarolinaaccidentattorney.com/#51643 carisoprodol alternatives - muscle relaxers soma carisoprodol

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol 350 mg where to buy carisoprodol - soma carisoprodol tablets 250 mg directions

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol class of drug - carisoprodol can you snort

Anonymous said...

[url=http://archive.org/details/paunokogo][img]http://emeds.biz/pics/spymobile.png[/img][/url]
phone tracker free download for blackberry http://spymobile81kc37.carbonmade.com/projects/4708508 free cell phone sms spy software [url=http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3440966] mobile phone gps tracking uk[/url] spy on cell phone free trial best cell phones spyware small spy video camera wireless
mamoleptino321 http://archive.org/details/brevemphaqu http://archive.org/details/dustbarttragex http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3440887
how to track a cell phone location in india http://archive.org/details/wordverconod spy dirty mo sunglasses white [url=http://archive.org/details/itavesyv] wireless spy audio recorder[/url] free android phone spy apps spy camera video watch manual himym season 7 episode 19 putlocker
http://spymobilehc66.carbonmade.com/projects/4708456 http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3440793 http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3440741
[url=http://ryslig.hanei.sridhar.dagmarchen.murf.forum.mythem.es/]monitor any cell phone for free[/url]
http://www.envynailspa.com/guest#comment-4075 http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=19591771&postID=115675452770130270&page=1&token=1364295507069&isPopup=true http://www.lynksgames.com/tokyo-disney-resort/comment-page-2/#comment-62645 http://learn-guitar-notes.learnguitareasily.org/2011/09/06/watch-how-to-play-a-g-over-b-gb-chord-on-guitar/#comment-93089 http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=1063020417900794038&postID=2008240640323677152&page=1&token=1362999089246
does at&t monitor text messages http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3440976 spy on cell phone free download [url=http://www.world66.com/member/spymobile_a3ijhfzt/] spy video recorder android[/url] telephone monitoring software free spy software for cell phones in india spy kids 4 wikia

Anonymous said...

wonderful points altogether, you just won a new reader.
What could you suggest about your publish that you made a
few days in the past? Any certain?

Have a look at my blog post - Cheap Oakley Sunglasses

Apcalis said...

Nice Post Love Reading Its

kamagra 100mg

generic Viagra 100mg

Anonymous said...

If some one desires to be updated with newest technologies therefore he must be pay a quick visit this site and bee up to date every day.



Review my web-site :: testosterone supplements natural